[DWJ] Georgette Heyer (also "what this list has given me")

Jackie E Stallcup jstallcup at juno.com
Sat Jan 5 23:09:23 EST 2008

Oh, dear.  It's so complicated!

I suppose I just don't want to start in the middle of a series, where I'm
supposed to know who everyone is already and what their inside jokes

Also, romp and skulduggery and Twins Who Cannot Be Told Apart sound good.
 Melancholy and upsetting do not.  (Let me put it this way:  I love To
Say Nothing of the Dog and re-read it fairly often.  I ate up Doomsday
Book, Lincoln's Dream and Passage, but have not wanted to re-read them
yet--too upsetting.  perhaps that tells you something about my pleasure
reading preferences.)

I also love Joan Aiken, both adult and children's books (though i like
less the last few in the Dido Twite Chronicles, which get positive

I haven't read many (any?) regency romances, but am quite open to such. 
Oh, I did read (and enjoy) Sorcery and Cecelia by Wrede and Stevener--is
that a regency? (displaying my ignorance!)

I'm in the middle of re-reading my Dorothy Sayers books (put back onto
them again by all the discussion of 1930s detective novels in Dog).  As a
general rule, I like mysteries best when there are interesting people in
them.  For example, I love Dick Francis not for the mysteries, which are
often not "true" mysteries (in the sense that the reader can work them
out if sufficiently attentive), but because I find the people and places
fascinating.  I didn't like Agatha Christie when i first tried her for
the same reason:  I felt stupid because I couldn't work out the mystery
and I found the people off-putting.  but I tried again (again, nudged by
Willis in Dog), with "The Mirror Cracked" and quite liked it because I
found Miss Marple very engaging in her fight to regain her independence
from a nurse who wanted to treat her like a child.

There are a million other books that I like, but those seem most relevant
to this discussion.

I'm writing down all of the suggestions and look forward to getting

Thank you!


On Sun, 6 Jan 2008 00:36:46 +0000 Minnow <minnow at belfry.org.uk> writes:
> >> Arabella or The Corinthian would be my suggestions.
> >> I'm also very partial to Venetia and for pure adventurous 
> silliness,
> >> The Talisman Ring.
> >I recommend The Grand Sophy -- it was my first Heyer, and it was a 
> fantastic
> >intoduction.
> I do love that question...
> Five down, twenty-five to go, more or less, if one discounts the
> modern/detective and the forsoothly ones.  <grin>
> I think it unlikely that *Cousin Kate* will be suggested, and 
> probably not
> *A Civil Contract* for a *first* Heyer, but most of the other 
> Regencies
> have their adherents, and quite a few of the more recent-historicals 
> before
> that date do too.
> The only other category is the historical Napoleonic Army ones, *The
> Spanish Bride* (Peninsular campaign) and *An Infamous Army*, which 
> have a
> lot of historical fact involved.  The first also has historical 
> persons as
> Heyero and Heyeroine (Captain Harry Smith and his wife Juanita) and 
> the
> second has the fictitious descendent of a family that is in two 
> previous
> books as its heroine and the H&H of another playing a major role.  I
> wouldn't start with either of those.
> Do you want melancholy, romp, moral dilemma, marital 
> misunderstanding,
> skullduggery, or a hot-air balloon and Dr Radcliffe's Restorative 
> Pork
> Jelly?  Are you partial to Terrible Dowager Grandmothers, or do you 
> prefer
> Twins Who Cannot Be Told Apart?  (One book has both.)  
> Cross-dressing or
> cross purposes?
> One rode a horse and the other rhododendron!
> Minnow
> _______________________________________________
> Dwj mailing list
> Dwj at suberic.net
> http://www.suberic.net/mailman/listinfo/dwj

More information about the Dwj mailing list