[DWJ] FW: New BookCrossing journal entry for A Sudden Wild Magic!

Belben, Philip (Energy Wholesale) Philip.Belben at eon-uk.com
Thu Feb 1 03:57:59 EST 2007

I've had a very interesting review of SWM from a bookcrosser I sent it
to a couple of years ago.  I thought I'd post it here for discussion.

-----Original Message-----

Someone has made a new journal entry on one of your books at
BookCrossing.com! We've displayed the entry below, but you can read all
the entries at http://bookcrossing.com/journal/1347225 anytime.

Book Title: A Sudden Wild Magic
Author:     Dianna Wynne Jones
Wednesday, January 31, 2007

I've just finished reading A Sudden Wild Magic. I'm very sorry for
so long to read it! I truly am! When I first started bookcrossing, I was
bit too excited to participate in RABCK's and the like, and got a load
books at once! (Later I learned this often happens with the newbies...)
I've been doing my best to read the books I've been given and pass them
but sometimes I've taken quite a long time to do so. Again, I apologize!

Well, I was very happy to have a chance to read this sci-fi / fantasy
adventure story! It was a bit different from what expected, since I've
read Charmed Life before (from Diana Wynne Jones) and that one was
at a decidedly younger audience. 

In the beginning I thought there was going to be a lot of sex in A
Wild Magic, but actually there was none, all the sex parts were sort of
skimmed over. Instead there was lots of soppy romance bits. I was a bit
disappointed because of that! Not that I'm a sex maniac or anything, and
reading about sex usually only makes me bored. It was just this feeling
got in the beginning of the book, the style felt so very "adult" first,
then it was a strange sort of a let-down to realize the book was far
"nicer" that I thought in the beginning.

I guess I need to explain a little about this, since the paragraph above
seems so weird all by itself. It's just that I've been reading some
extremely sexist and conservative sci-fi books lately, where women are
portrayed as wifes and mothers only, and I sort of thought that A Sudden
Wild Magic was going to be more liberal somehow. And it was, I don't
that, but still there was quite a bit of gender stereotyping thrown in. 

The sex thing had to do with the fact that the woman troops were sent
the citadel Arth to have sex with the men, and thereby disturb the
precarious balance of powers in that celibate community. Instead of just
getting down to business, the women all got very dreamy-eyed and
and started actually falling in love with the mages they were supposed
throw off power. I just thought it was such a stereotyped way to look at
women: they can't "use" their sexuality, not even to save their own
universe (!), unless they're romantically in love. I also found the
of Zillah and Mark a bit syrupy, and I wished it hadn't been so very
central to the whole story.

Some gender stereotypes are at play in the universe of Arth and
as well. The male mages are leading this celibate, unhappy life and
training other males in an army-like fashion. Their home citadel has no
creativity, only bland food and joyless atmosphere, and is generally
of the warm female touch. When the women from Earth arrive, they bring
female touch by cooking better food, teaching the men to dance, and by
generally caring and sharing and being motherly over the men (instead of
just having the wild sex they were supposed to). Doesn't that sound
stereotyped, or what? 

At the same time the women mages down at the Pentarchy are depicted as a
decidedly worse bunch that the male ones up on Arth. We don't actually
learn much about what the women mages <i>do</i>, but they seem to be
an uncaring bitches who dress too well and wear too much make-up and
perfume. In the end of the book the male mages are set to right and they
reform their world, but the readers don't ever get to know if the female
ones stay cold, uncaring bitches. Some more gender stereotyping there,

Now that I've had my say about this gender bias, I can concentrate on
I liked about A Sudden Wild Magic. I like the way Diana Wynne Jones
clearly and beautifully, and she can be funny and serious at the same
Sometimes the text has a definite Terry Pratchett'ish feel to it,
especially the part where Gladys and the High Head unwillingly start
cooperation. (They remind me of Granny Weatherwax and the Archchancellor
the Unseen University in the Discworld novel Equal Rites. I'll bet Diana
Wynne Jones has read the book!)

All in all, A Sudden Wild magic was a nice read, and a lot better that
chauvinistic sci-fi books I've been reading lately. It didn't turn out
be my all-time favourite sci-fi novel, but very much worth the
I'm so happy that I got the book from PDB11 - thanks again! 

I'm thinking about setting the book free in my favourite sci-fi and
releasing event: that is, at the national sci-fi convention called
The next one is going to be only next summer, so I'll have to wait a
bit. I
think it will be worth the wait, though, because I usually get really
catches from that event and the bookcrossing books released there are
picked up at a great speed! So, unless I figure out something better,
releasing this book at the next Finncon!

    By harmaja from Espoo, Uusimaa  Finland
    Book Rating: 7 out of 10
___________________________ Disclaimer Notice ____________________
This message and any attachments are confidential and should only
be read by those to whom they are addressed. If you are not the
intended recipient, please contact us, delete the message from your
computer and destroy any copies. Any distribution or copying without
our prior permission is prohibited.

Internet communications are not always secure and therefore the
E.ON Group does not accept legal responsibility for this message.
The recipient is responsible for verifying its authenticity before
acting on the contents. Any views or opinions presented are solely
those of the author and do not necessarily
represent those of the E.ON Group.

E.ON UK plc, Westwood Way, Westwood Business Park,
Coventry, CV4 8LG.
Registered in England & Wales No. 2366970

E.ON UK Trading Ltd, Westwood Way, Westwood Business Park,
Coventry, CV4 8LG
Registered in England & Wales No. 4178314

E.ON UK Trading Ltd is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services
Authority to carry out energy investment activities.

Telephone +44 (0) 2476 42 4000
Fax +44 (0) 2476 42 5432

More information about the Dwj mailing list