Charles de Lint

Emma Comerford emmaco at
Tue Mar 8 20:48:41 EST 2005

Quoting Roslyn <rosgross at>:

> >> I thought _Swim the Moon_ could have been trimmed down and edited,
> >> but I really liked it. I found it aatmospheric and quite haunting.
> >> I was going to get hold of _The Wild Reel_ but now I've gor second
> >> thoughts!
> >>
> >> Ros
> >
> > It's fluff. Entertaining fluff but fluff none-the-less. Not one I'll 
> > re-read
> > as I did with Swim the Moon.
> Hmm! Thanks. It's good to have prior warning about these things!
> Ros

Whereas I love _The Wild Reel_ mostly (I think) because I know the places in it and thought they were 
reflected very well :) I didn't like the main character in _Swim the Moon_ and didn't really care what 
happened to him, which never improves a book.

To unsubscribe, email dwj-request at with the body "unsubscribe".
Visit the archives at

More information about the Dwj mailing list