Christianity in the Chrestoverse

Dorian E. Gray israfel at
Wed Jul 20 16:23:58 EDT 2005

Kyra said...

>> We have no evidence from which to assume that other gods don't exist in 
>> XII
>> B (or indeed, any of Series XII) - at least, not that I can think of.
>> Assorted non-Christian deities may well be in existence.  I could see the
>> Hindu pantheon, for instance, existing at least as much as the
>> Jewish/Christian/Muslim god.
> Yes, that was kind of my point.  If other things that can be called gods
> really exist, in a way that's known by at least powerful people like
> Chrestomanci, where do they fit in to Christian theology?

For ordinary humans?  Probably the same way things work in this world. 
Assume they're false gods, and possibly try to convert their misguided 

At god level (so to speak)?  I would be inclined to think that the relevant 
text would be "Thou shalt have no other gods before Me."  This doesn't, to 
my thinking, say that other gods don't exist.  It just says that a follower 
of this god must not worship any others.  So the god of the People of the 
Book is well aware that there are other gods in the world, just as real as 
he is.  He's just not going to have his followers worshipping anyone else as 

As for theology...I'd tend to think that humans in general don't know that 
other gods than their own are real, so theology goes as theology goes here. 
How rare persons such as nine-lived enchanters, who (presumably) know that 
there are many real gods, reconcile that knowledge with their own personal 
religions...well, that's up to them, really.


To unsubscribe, email dwj-request at with the body "unsubscribe".
Visit the archives at

More information about the Dwj mailing list