word order (was Re: Random DWJ discovery of the day)
rohina at shaw.ca
Wed Apr 6 11:48:36 EDT 2005
Anna Zofia Skarzynska wrote:
>Both are by Steven Pinker and they are called The Language Instinct and
>Words and Rules.
>I dug them out last night and they Have The Answers! A lot of time is
>devoted to the study of just how children acquire language- all very
>pertinent to this discussion and much better put than I could ever hope to
>do. Absolutely fascinating and very illuminating (from the historical
>linguistics background and point of view I found it filled gaps and
>contributed to the elaborate 3D interactive and ever expanding construct in
>my brain which is labelled Language).
Okay, this is why you think I don't understand the issues. I think
Pinker is almost entirely wrong in the way he theorises language
aquisition. I know he's popular, but there are lots of experts on
language who don't agree with him, for various reasons. There's a lot of
debate about the nature of language; I think Pinker is almost
intellectually dishonest because he very rarerly acknowledges that there
is room for debate in what he is saying.
To unsubscribe, email dwj-request at suberic.net with the body "unsubscribe".
Visit the archives at http://suberic.net/dwj/list/
More information about the Dwj