A little more Deep Secret for Ika (Was: Re: Favourites/ Least favourites)

Hallie O'Donovan hallieod at indigo.ie
Sat Dec 18 02:09:21 EST 2004

Ika asked why people put Deep Secret near the top of their favourite 
lists, and all sorts of wonderful replies were forthcoming, with 
which I agreed heartily.  But I've been thinking about it a quite a 
bit and realised there was still more which influenced its being one 
of my favourites, so am belatedly tossing my 2 cents in too.

Basically, I'm just a romantic sap, *if* the romance feels true to me 
(sentimental drivel doesn't work!), and Rupert and Maree are one of 
my favourite DWJ couples.  I love the funny, antagonistic 
Elizabeth/Darcy beginning, especially as it's seen from 'the inside' 
- and how wonderful it is to see Rupert's admission of his Pygmalion 
fantasy about Maree!  I love Rupert's uptightness and Maree's 
prickliness  and their getting to unbend a bit over the books at the 
con.  I love the fact that she says the 'unforgivable thing' to 
Rupert, and knows it was unforgivable and is sorry for having done it 
- neither of these two is remotely close to being a cardboard cut-out 
- and especially not a cut-out romantic hero/heroine.  Most of all I 
love the part after she's been stripped.  Rupert's realisation of the 
level of his feeling for her is so wonderfully portrayed.  I love 
that he thinks about her until he sees her completely, and part of 
what he sees is that 'she saw deep into things.'  And I love the way 
the journey to Babylon is based on such a subtle blend of 
self-reliance and complete mutual need and trust.   How true is that? 
Without its being the least bit in your face about it, it's also cool 
that it's Rupert who stays waiting (literally keeping the home fires 
burning) while Maree 'looks beyond'!  And then she comes back and is 
transformed, but by being totally herself - filling her own outlines. 
Great stuff...

As Ika (and several other people also, IIRC) haven't read all the 
Dalemarks, I'd better stay away from the couple in them, but other 
romantic couples?  Dearly as I love Howl (the book!), it's not much 
for the romance.  Polly and Tom are wonderful because of that long 
heroic friendship.  Millie and Christopher lovely as an adult couple 
and fun as a potential one but we don't see quite enough of them. 
And I've already lowered myself in everyone's eyes by dismissing the 
love at first sight romances in Year of the Griffin, so perhaps 
shouldn't do so again. ;)


To unsubscribe, email dwj-request at suberic.net with the body "unsubscribe".
Visit the archives at http://suberic.net/dwj/list/

More information about the Dwj mailing list