The Merlin Conspiracy (no spoilers)

Ding, Kylie (KAM.RIC) Kylie.Ding at
Tue Mar 18 21:00:21 EST 2003

Don't get me wrong, there were bits of it I loved.  Some of the characters, most of the concepts and all of the settings!  Though I did find some of the characters very irritating as well.  I think my problem is in the way it all hung together.  I'm not to good at literary criticism, and I find it really hard to put my finger on what I don't like about some books, and I find it even harder to express it in writing.  But when I'd finished The Merlin Conspiracy I had a bit of a sense of disappointment.  I didn't get that with Deep Secret or Year of the Griffin.

I did rush the reading and I will have to go back and read it again to digest it properly.  I should be all fired up and hopefully have firm opinions and criticism sorted out in a couple of weeks time when the debate hits the list.


> >
> > PS I've read The Merlin Conspiracy and enjoyed it a lot, 
> but I wouldn't
> put it up there with her best.
> This may be a bit premature, but for the record I disagree. I 
> think it's an
> amazingly inventive and  exciting book, right up there with 
> Deep Secret (and
> a considerable improvement on Year of the Griffin...). I do have one
> quibble, which those who know my views on fantasy monarchies won't be
> surprised by, but it's not a serious one in context.
> But no doubt this debate will take off properly in a few 
> weeks, so I'll hang
> further fire till then.
> Charlie
> --
> To unsubscribe, email dwj-request at with the body 
> "unsubscribe".
> Visit the archives at

To unsubscribe, email dwj-request at with the body "unsubscribe".
Visit the archives at

More information about the Dwj mailing list