Genre prejudice

Hallie O'Donovan hallieod at
Fri Jul 18 18:02:49 EDT 2003


>Yes, sorry, I meant that a lot of Atwood's work did fit Wolverton's 
>definition (no doubt this is the source of the praise from the New 
>Yorker). The speculative works are perhaps less likely to do so, but 
>I was thinking specifically of The Blind Assassin and some of the 
>short stories when I made the comment. I haven't yet read the newest 
>one, which is supposedly another speculative book.

Ok, thanks.  It was the newest one, Orxy and Crake, that I read, and 
it is speculative, which is why I was surprised.  It was very 
impressive, though I was a bit reluctant beforehand, not having a 
high tolerance for bleak or grim.  Not so sure 'enjoyed' is the right 
term, but  neither is Ven's slogging up a sodding great mountain 
analogy.  Maybe a slightly too-spicy for comfort but really 
nutritious and tasty meal?

To unsubscribe, email dwj-request at with the body "unsubscribe".
Visit the archives at

More information about the Dwj mailing list