: fantasy monarchies
margaret at onr.com
Sun Feb 2 13:44:29 EST 2003
>I think the explanation may lie even deeper than JRRT's influence. Why would
>it be unthinkable for Disney - a good republican, no doubt - to make a film
>called The Lion President? Yet it would be hard to cite Tolkien's influence
>there, or even that of the Middle Ages. Must we turn to Jungian archetypes
>for an explanation?
Well...maybe all these fantasy writers had the same American Government
101 class that I had in college...a class guaranteed to induce instant
coma when thinking about politics. "Aaaah, I don't want to think about
political systems, let's just have a king and be done with it."
No, actually I think you're right. There are certain themes that keep
coming up. The True Heir, the Quest for the Magic Spatula, etc. Hmm.
Maybe I should find Bruno Bettelheim's _The Uses of Enchantment_, he may
have something interesting to say on the subject. (I've been ticked off
at Bettelheim ever since he wrote an article in the early 60's opining
that college education was wasted on girls because they were just going
to get married and be housewives anyway....but maybe 40 years is long
enough to hold a grudge <g> (I'm still mad at Joseph Campbell for
similar reasons but am not ready to let go of that grudge yet))
To unsubscribe, email dwj-request at suberic.net with the body "unsubscribe".
Visit the archives at http://suberic.net/dwj/list/
More information about the Dwj