Re Dalemark Chronology

Melissa Proffitt Melissa at
Fri Apr 12 23:50:25 EDT 2002

On Fri, 12 Apr 2002 22:36:37 -0400 (EDT), deborah wrote:

>The counter problem is people who believe any alternate world
>books are automatically fantasy.  This happens to Cynthia Voigt's
>Jackaroo/Wings of the Falcon/On Fortune's Wheel/Elske world.  Not
>a spec of magic, just a world that isn't ours.  but with our
>physics and biology and such.

So, does a book have to have magic in order to be called "fantasy"?

This was an issue with a book I reviewed last year.  The title is _The White
Dove_ and I had very low expectations because it began with a little
sermonette by the author, essentially saying that it was a fantasy, but not
the kind with magic in it.  Just people triumphing over evil by their common
virtues of honesty, faith, etc. instead of depending on nonexistent "magic".
I have issues with this attitude--fortunately the book wasn't so hardnosed.
But it made me wonder why the author felt so compelled to explain that it
wasn't a magical fantasy.  And what, then, do you call it?  Alternate
history has a well-carved niche, but this was its own world (despite being
primarily a story about revolution, using themes and events derived from
"real" history).  Does it fit into the very broad category of fantasy, or is
it something else?

Melissa Proffitt
To unsubscribe, email dwj-request at with the body "unsubscribe".
Visit the archives at

More information about the Dwj mailing list