A long ramble: Regency fantasy, book recommendations, etc.

Jacob Proffitt Jacob at Proffitt.com
Mon Sep 3 15:36:59 EDT 2001

---Original Message From: Philip.Belben at powertech.co.uk
> One thing that bothers me about some fantasy series.  They 
> often cover centuries, or even millennia, of their world's 
> history, and yet the world seems technologically stuck in the 
> early middle ages, with no explanation as to why. Sometimes I 
> think it may be merely because the writers are romanticising 
> the period.  Science Fiction writers don't seem to have this 
> trouble, but then they are used to writing in a genre large 
> sections of which are concerned mainly with technological progress.

Sci. Fi. Has it's own version of this.  I love it when they have
galactic civilizations that have been around for hundreds of years
essentially unchanged.  On Earth, we've had a tough time keeping any
single government around for longer than a couple centuries.  The
longest lasting governments I can think of are Rome and China, but both
of those underwent *substantial* change--to such an extent that I have
kind of a hard time calling them the same government.

> Alan Dean Foster, whose SF I recommend, but not his fantasy.  
> Very readable.  I don't think it would stand up to 
> hard-science scrutiny, but it's still good SF.

I *loved* the Flinx novels.  It's been ten years or more since I read
them, but I wouldn't mind reading them again just to see if the memory
holds.  I think he wrote _Quozl_ as well and that book stands as one of
the few fundamental stories I've read that changed the way I think about
some things.  The story was so unique and fresh that I can still
remember significant details as well as the broader storyline.

> To me, "Urban" means "to do with cities".  We finally settled 
> on two competing definitions last time - "Fantasy of, rather 
> than merely in, a city", favoured by me, and "Fantasy which 
> contrasts magic and modern city life as light and darkness" 
> (I think) favoured by Mr and Mrs Proffitt (who will no doubt 
> pop up with a far better statement of their definition).

Nah.  That's about what my definition comes down to.  Charles DeLint
serves as my measuring stick for my kind of Urban Fantasy.

Jacob Proffitt

To unsubscribe, email dwj-request at suberic.net with the body "unsubscribe".
Visit the archives at http://suberic.net/dwj/list/

More information about the Dwj mailing list