Religion and fantasy
ncase at hedbergmaps.com
Mon Jul 23 15:24:25 EDT 2001
Georgia: no offense taken from me, at least! I have thought about
this some myself, and I think the way you phrased the question
triggered the response that in a way the question is itself a red
herring. the relation of one's beliefs to an orthodoxy has little to
do with ability to create fantasy, or maybe even has an inverse
Here's what I think: Everyone has beliefs that can be classified as
"religious." Some of us have beliefs that follow received teaching
more-or-less closely, and some of us have beliefs that allow us to
participate in religious groups (churches, synagogues, covens, etc.)
even if we are not by nature orthodox. Some have beliefs that by
their nature put them outside religious communities.
Jones' writing, and indeed most fantasy, has an element of religious
thought-experiment behind it, some more blatant, some less. Because
fantasy writers are tinkering with basic cosmological questions, you
would think they were all deeply agnostic, but this simply isn't so.
Orson Scott Card and Diane Duane, are, respectively, devoutly Mormon
and Catholic. Those are two I can think of off the top of my head,
but I'm sure there are many many others.
I actually think clear religious belief (which can be easier within a
religious tradition) can be an aid to thinking "outside the box." If
you're struggling to figure out the basics in the real world, how
much energy do you have left to figure it out in an alternative world?
But the key in this regard to being a good writer of any kind is (it
seems to me) less the makeup of one's belief system and more the lack
of fear about one's beliefs (and lack of fear in general) that let
you use them in your work unprotected.
>I was interested to see from the alternate identity returns that
>quite a few of those of us on the list have religious beliefs.
>I was wondering about how this influences the way you read DWJ (and
>other fantasy). I haven't read anything DWJ has said about whether
>she is a Christian, but on the evidence of the books I assume she's
>not: I can't think of any of her books where the worlds she
>describes have any kind of benevolent, omniscient and immortal
>supernatural figure wch might be comparable to the Judeo-Christian
>Do people think that they read fantasy differently if they have
>religious beliefs? I'm about halfway through one of Charles
>Williams' fantasy novels, _The Place of the Lion_, wch has the usual
>good v. evil plot, but as Williams was a convinced Christian the
>good and evil are in this case the Biblical heaven and hell - very
>much as in Lewis' _Out of the Silent Planet_ trilogy. I'm finding
>the book gripping, but I wonder whether my reaction to it would be
>different if I were a Christian. Or do we put our own views of the
>world on hold whilst we read fantasy?
>I hope I haven't offended anyone on the list by asking about these
>matters; I would be very interested in any responses anyone has.
>Express yourself @ another.com
To unsubscribe, email dwj-request at suberic.net with the body "unsubscribe".
Visit the archives at http://suberic.net/dwj/list/
More information about the Dwj