Time of the Ghost, Spoilers, Questions on the Ending
klj at sccs.swarthmore.edu
Fri Apr 6 20:37:46 EDT 2001
Hmm. . . I'm really going to need to ask you two about this, now. But
to my mind:
1) Fenella could easily have made it up - but I have the feeling she
wouldn't have told anyone if she had. If Fenella had made it up, I doubt
anyone would have ever heard about it.
2) Imo's the one you suggest, Melissa. But I just don't see it. It seems
to me to be far too. . . I don't know. I realize that the worship of
Monigan wasn't gruesome until Julian made it that way, so that's not a
problem, but I just don't feel that Imo's mind works that way. Imo
certainly has a good imagination - but, from experience, I know that
making up an imaginary religion takes a certain amount and kind of
discipline which I don't really think she is suggested to have in the
book - she does get frustrated fairly easily.
3) Surely no one would argue it was Sally - I don't even think I'm going
to dignify this suggestion by arguing against it ;-).
4) And I can very easily see Cart as doing it. Maybe this is because I
tend to imagine Cart as making things up in much the same way I do. Part
of it is inspiration - and I think we get Cart having inspiration
throughout the book. But the other part is actually having the mind
needed to organize that inspiration, and I certainly think that Cart is
the most likely of the four sisters to have both of these
qualities. Fenella and Imo both do well on the inspiration, especially
Fenella. I could certainly see Sally as organizing it. But Cart seems
capable to do both - and sufficiently interested in organizing the family
into following her, which I would say Fenella at least isn't.
Of course, Kyla, you have my copy of the book - so this is all
from memory - I could be completely forgetting something obvious here ;-).
"Crucification was Rome's way of punishing criminals - the only reason
it's so glorified in religion is because they happened to do it to
Christ. If they'd hung him up on a meat hook instead, then meat hooks
would be. . ."
---Amber Michelle Kitch, Mother of All Humanity
On Fri, 6 Apr 2001, Melissa Proffitt wrote:
> On Thu, 5 Apr 2001 14:17:40 -0400 (EDT), Kyla Tornheim wrote:
> >It always seemed a bit surprising to me that Cart was the one
> >who made up the worship of Monigan. It doesn't seem quite right.
> Yes, it really seems as though it should have been Isobel or someone else,
> doesn't it? But on the other hand, I can imagine Cart having "grown up" a
> little since the time she invented it, so when we meet her finally she's not
> the same person who invented it. Like Polly's friend Nina, taking up new
> interests and dropping them, but in a more normal and less shallow
> way...just the consequences of growing older. Nina makes a religion out of
> it, practically. But this is just off the top of my head, so I have no idea
> if it makes any sense.
> I should be doing other things right now, like laundry. But this is so much
> more fun than laundry.
> Melissa Proffitt
To unsubscribe, email dwj-request at suberic.net with the body "unsubscribe".
Visit the archives at http://suberic.net/dwj/list/
More information about the Dwj