Mitt and Maewen

Jacob Proffitt Jacob at
Tue Sep 19 14:10:40 EDT 2000

On Wed, 20 Sep 2000 00:02:44 +1000, Sally Odgers wrote:

>It is, of course, a clich? to speak of the genius who is a duffer at games
>so I was unreasonably miffed to learn that Alex was afraid of any animal
>bigger than a goldfish and couldn't swim. James, a fisherman/swimmer, came
>home from school camp and remarked placidly that he'd "got Alex through" the
>water sports part of their course. It seems he loaded the poor lad into a
>2-man kayak, assured him he wouldn't let him drown and gave him a
>cram-course in paddling.
>Does anyone have any theory about this "intellectual wimp" clich? came into
>being? *Is* it just a clich?, or was Alex really typical?

If I may be so bold as to offer myself as an example.  I have been very
fortunate in my skills and talents.  I have a natural bent for mathematics
and logical puzzles.  I am, in fact, a geek in the modern use of the term.
Although I'm not as sharp as Alex obviously is, I have tested at genius

On the other hand, and this is the part that should really make you sick, I
also have some skill in physical pursuits.  I used to finish in the top
three in races in PE no matter what length and without any training, often
beating guys on the track team.  I have some natural poise as well that
makes things like soccer and basketball a natural pursuit.  I actually *did*
pursue some Martial Arts and was a top student and sometimes instructor.  My
instructor used to be amazed because he only had to show me something once.

Now, to get back to Sally's question, I can say with some emphasis that
there is a direct antagonism in physical pursuits directed at anyone who
excels in other areas.  Geeks are not welcomed in athletic programs even if
they can help the team win.  When a jock is beat on his own grounds by
someone he feels inferior to in other areas, well, it isn't pretty and it
isn't fun.  Plus, athletic pursuits leave a multitude of openings for the
very basest of human impulses to find outlet.  Not a good combination.

If you combine that with the simple fact that mental pursuits are just
easier than physical ones, well, it's no wonder the clich? is validated.

To unsubscribe, email dwj-request at with the body "unsubscribe".
Visit the archives at

More information about the Dwj mailing list