idealism/sexism in HPIV

Anita Graham amgraham at
Sun Oct 8 09:50:56 EDT 2000

At 03:19  06-10-00 -0400, Wholergo at wrote:

>In re sexism AND idealism, does it seem to anyone that Herminone is ridiculed
>for her idealism?  Her opposition to what are basically colonila relations is
>made to seem silly.  Not a good message for kids or anyone.
>Robin Gillespie

You are right. As an adult reader, though, I assumed - and still do - that 
she will be proved right in the end, and that her fight for the house-elves 
will eventually be a positive thing.


More information about the Dwj mailing list