Muggles for Harry Potter

Britta Koch bkoch at
Fri Jun 16 09:18:17 EDT 2000


I just got a shock from the "Moral Majority":

Apparently, Harry Potter books are banned from school libraries and classroooms 
in some U.S. states and in New Zealand, which has caused some people to form a group
called "Muggle for Harry Potter" ( )

I read some of the causes they listed:
- it's violent
- it's icky-bah witchcraft
- it's against families (because the Dursleys are so horrible)
- muggles (= we) are portrayed as stupid losers

I nearly couldn't believe it! I think banning books from schools is wrong - 
if you have a problem with some of the issues, why not read the books in 
school and talk about them?

And to bring this back on topic: there's probably lots of things in dwj 
some people would have similar objections to...

Oh, and another one of those half-forgotten books from childhood / puberty
is one where people wanted to ban "Tom Sawyer" and "Huckleberry Finn"
from being read, on the grounds that women were portrayed as stupid, and that Tom
on the boat just with the escaped slave is also not ok... anyone know it? 

Britta, whose first English dwj arrived yesterday (Deep Secrets), yay!

To unsubscribe, email dwj-request at with the body "unsubscribe".
Visit the archives at

More information about the Dwj mailing list